Crime

West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt Indicted on Theft and Fraud Charges in Tax Deed Scheme

West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt, 66, was indicted on nine theft counts over tax deeds allegedly issued to benefit a friend and business associate.

Official portrait of West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt
Photo: BallotReady / West Virginia State Auditor's Office

West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt was indicted Monday by a federal grand jury on charges that he used his office to steal nine tax-delinquent properties for a longtime friend and business associate. United States Attorney Moore Capito announced the charges in Charleston.

The indictment alleges Hunt, 66, of Charleston, schemed to benefit Robert Lisle Johns, 66, through the improper issuance of tax deeds by the auditor’s office. Johns is associated with a business entity that sought to buy nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties.

Career employees in the auditor’s office had determined the properties were not legally eligible for deed issuance, prosecutors said. Hunt, who took office in January 2025 after being elected the previous year, overruled them and personally signed deeds for eight of the properties on March 28, 2025, and for the ninth on June 6, 2025.

The deeds went to a landholding company, MAPA LLC, according to an investigation by West Virginia Watch, which first reported on Hunt’s actions earlier this month. In June 2025, Hunt’s office hired Johns as a full-time special counsel.

Four Charged With Theft, Two With Lying to the FBI

Hunt was not indicted alone. Each of the four men — Hunt, Johns, deputy chief of staff David Keith Cole, 57, and general counsel Frederic Scott Caudill, 59 — faces nine counts of theft of property. Cole also serves as office manager of Hunt’s private law firm.

Cole and Caudill were each also charged with one count of making materially false statements to federal investigators. Prosecutors allege Caudill made false statements to FBI agents during an October 26 interview about the disputed tax deeds, and that Cole made false statements during an October 6 interview about the property transfers and his approval of timecards.

In a separate indictment, Hunt, Cole and auditor’s office employee Marie Ann Hoffmann, 66, face bank fraud charges. Prosecutors allege Hoffmann submitted false state timecards for hours she worked at Hunt’s private law firm, on Friday afternoons between May 2025 and September 2026, and that Hunt and Cole aided and abetted the fraud.

The theft counts each carry a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000. The false-statement counts carry up to five years in prison, and the bank fraud count carries up to 30 years in prison and a fine of up to $1 million.

None of the defendants was in custody when the charges were announced, and Capito said they would turn themselves in soon. He said the investigation is ongoing and declined to say whether further charges could follow. The West Virginia Democratic Party called on Hunt to resign. Hunt has said he is innocent of the charges and will vigorously defend himself. An indictment is only an allegation, and all defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.